Skip to main content

Supreme Court Decision: Meigs County traffic stop unconstitutionally prolonged for K9 sniff

Court News Ohio

A Meigs County sheriff’s deputy violated a driver’s constitutional rights by unreasonably extending a traffic stop to perform a canine sniff, the Supreme Court of Ohio ruled today.

In a 6-1 decision, the Supreme Court reversed a judgment of the Fourth District Court of Appeals, which had determined that a 2019 traffic stop could be prolonged by five to 10 minutes for another officer to arrive based on “officer safety” concerns. The Fourth District’s ruling had affirmed the convictions of John Kincaid.

Kincaid contested his convictions, arguing that the canine sniff and subsequent search, which led to the discovery of narcotics, were unconstitutional because the prosecution failed to provide evidence to justify extending the traffic stop.

Writing for the Court majority, Chief Justice Sharon L. Kennedy explained that the Court had agreed to consider whether officer safety concerns could justify extending the stop in order to conduct a canine sniff. She wrote that the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2015 Rodriguez v. United States decision does not create an exception that allows law enforcement to extend the seizure of a driver based on officer safety when the safety concern is not related to the mission of the traffic stop.

“Officer safety does not justify prolonging a stop for a canine sniff since a sniff is not part of a traffic stop’s mission,” she wrote. “This means that prolonging a traffic stop to ensure officer safety before conducting a canine sniff is unconstitutional, because prolonging the stop is not necessary to complete the ordinary inquiries incident to the stop.”

Chief Justice Kennedy also noted that the Meigs County Prosecutor’s Office changed its theory of why the stop was justified when it argued the case before the Supreme Court. The prosecutor contended that Deputy Tylun Campbell was still completing tasks related to the traffic stop when the canine alerted to the drugs in Kincaid’s car.

The Court majority stated that it is the prosecutor’s burden to prove the traffic stop tasks were still ongoing when the canine alerted to the presence of drugs, but there is no proof in the trial court record indicating Campbell was still completing traffic stop tasks at that time.

Justices Patrick F. Fischer, R. Patrick DeWine, Jennifer Brunner, Joseph T. Deters, and Daniel R. Hawkins joined Chief Justice Kennedy’s opinion.

In a dissenting opinion, Justice Megan E. Shanahan agreed that Rodriguez does not permit officers to prolong a traffic stop for a canine sniff based on officer-safety concerns. However, she concluded that Campbell’s testimony about the sequence of events, together with the brief wait for backup, permitted a reasonable inference that ordinary traffic-stop inquiries remained ongoing when the canine alerted. She would have upheld the stop and affirmed the Fourth District’s judgment.

“Based on that sequence of events and because of the brief duration of the wait, I would conclude that the record permits the reasonable inference that some ordinary traffic-stop inquiries remained ongoing when the canine alerted,” she stated.

Add new comment

This is not for publication.
This is not for publication.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
Article comments are not posted immediately to the Web site. Each submission must be approved by the Web site editor, who may edit content for appropriateness. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission while the web site editor reviews and approves it. Note: All information on this form is required. Your telephone number and email address is for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.
CAPTCHA This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.