DeWine announces Science of Reading Audit results for Ohio colleges and universities
Ohio Governor Mike DeWine joined Ohio Department of Higher Education (ODHE) Chancellor Mike Duffey this week to announce the results of a recent audit into educator preparation programs (EPPs) at colleges and universities across the state.
COLUMBUS — Ohio Governor Mike DeWine joined Ohio Department of Higher Education (ODHE) Chancellor Mike Duffey this week to announce the results of a recent audit into educator preparation programs (EPPs) at colleges and universities across the state.
The audit – https://dam.assets.ohio.gov/image/upload/highered.ohio.gov/science-of-r… – was conducted to determine the extent to which college EPPs in Ohio are aligned with the Science of Reading, as required by state law.
“Decades of research tells us the Science of Reading gives students of all ability levels the best chance to become strong, independent readers,” said Governor DeWine. “Our kids only have one chance to grow up. We have an obligation to act with great urgency to make sure every future teacher going through our college programs is learning the best way to teach reading.”
In 2023, Governor DeWine worked alongside the Ohio General Assembly to require schools of all levels to become aligned with the Science of Reading. State law gave Ohio colleges and universities that educate future teachers until Jan. 1, 2025, to become fully aligned.
State law also required ODHE to lead an audit of all EPPs to ensure compliance. A review panel that included ODHE and the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce (ODEW) together selected The Meadows Center for Preventing Educational Risk at the University of Texas to conduct the audits, which began on Jan. 1, 2025, and continued throughout spring semester 2025.
After a detailed review process, Governor DeWine and Chancellor Duffey released the audit results today.
The audit evaluated all 48 institutions statewide with 12-Hour Reading and Literacy Core courses. Of them, 33 programs received a final rating of “In Alignment,” five programs received a final rating of “Partial Alignment,” and 10 programs received a final rating of “Not in Alignment.” (Details provided below)
“Many colleges are excelling with their implementation of the Science of Reading. Not only will this improve their students’ job prospects, but it will also make future generations of children better readers,” said Governor DeWine. “On the other hand, the audit found that there were still several institutions that had more work to do to become fully aligned.”
With the release of these audit results, institutions have one year from today to become fully aligned with the Science of Reading.
If any institutions do not meet this deadline, state law requires the Chancellor of Higher Education to revoke approval for their reading/literacy educator preparation programs.
“We understood going in that getting all of our institutions to 100% alignment with the law would require considerable time and effort,” said Chancellor Duffey. “The good news is that we are seeing tremendous progress. Just as a teacher does not expect every student to ace the test, we did not expect our colleges to be practically perfect in every way. We are feeling positive, however, about the ability of every institution to meet the standard within the time provided by the General Assembly – one year from today.”
Chancellor Duffey speaks at Governor DeWine's press conference to unveil results of Science of Reading Audit.
Chancellor Duffey speaks at Governor DeWine's press conference to unveil results of Science of Reading Audit.
Each of the 10 institutions that received a rating of “Not in Alignment” at the time of the audit have since submitted a formal attestation to ODHE pledging that – as of today – they are now in compliance with the law.
“This is good news. But the law also requires us to be certain that this is accurate,” said Governor DeWine. “So we will be going back out to every one of these institutions in 2026 to verify that they have come into full alignment with the Science of Reading.”
Audit Results
EPPs were evaluated in two main areas:
Best practices supporting the Science of Reading. ODHE collaborated with college and university leaders to establish 73 “audit metrics” to measure how well schools are implementing the Science of Reading.
Any observations of banned teaching methods (e.g. “three-cueing”) which are now illegal in Ohio.
In Alignment
To be considered “In Alignment,” institutions needed to meet at least 71 out of 73 audit metrics AND have zero violations for banned teaching practices.
33 institutions received an “In Alignment” rating. They include:
Ashland University
Baldwin Wallace University
Bluffton University
Cedarville University
College of Wooster
Franciscan University of Steubenville
Franklin University
Heidelberg University
Hiram College
John Carroll University
Kent State University
Lake Erie College
Lourdes University
Malone University
Marietta College
Miami University
Mount St. Joseph University
Mount Vernon Nazarene University
Muskingum University
Ohio Northern University
Otterbein University
Shawnee State University
The University of Akron
University of Cincinnati
University of Dayton
University of Findlay
University of Mount Union
University of Rio Grande
Walsh University
Wilmington College
Wittenberg University
Xavier University
Youngstown State University
Partial Alignment
To be considered in “Partial Alignment,” institutions needed to meet between 50 and 70 out of 73 audit metrics AND have zero violations for banned teaching practices.
Five institutions received a “Partial Alignment” rating. They include:
Capital University
God’s Bible School & College
Ohio Wesleyan University
Ursuline College
Western Governors University
Not in Alignment
All 10 institutions considered “Not in Alignment” were rated in this category for having one or more violations for banned teaching practices. Institutions could have also been rated in this category for meeting fewer than 50 metrics, although there were no instances of that occurring.
10 institutions received a “Not in Alignment” rating. They include:
Bowling Green State University
Central State University
Cleveland State University
Defiance College
Ohio Christian University
Ohio Dominican University
Ohio University
The Ohio State University
The University of Toledo
Wright State University
* * *
••• Publisher's note: A free press is critical to having well-informed voters and citizens. While some news organizations opt for paid websites or costly paywalls, The Highland County Press has maintained a free newspaper and website for the last 26 years for our community. If you would like to contribute to this service – and want it to continue – it would be greatly appreciated. Donations to help offset ever-rising expenses may be made to: The Highland County Press, P.O. Box 849, Hillsboro, Ohio 45133. Please include "for website" on the memo line.