Skip to main content

Judge Greer set to rule on alleged child abuse case

Lead Summary
By
Caitlin Forsha-crforsha@gmail.com

Highland County Juvenile & Probate Court Judge Kevin Greer said the “evidence is overwhelming” in finding that two Highland County children were abused, neglected and dependent Friday, Dec. 4, in a hearing involving a mother also indicted on three felony counts earlier this year.

As previously reported, following a complaint filed in Highland County Juvenile Court Thursday, Sept. 10, Greer granted Highland County Children Services temporary custody of two children on Sept. 14. The judge said at the hearing that the allegations were among the worst he’s seen in his tenure as judge. The judge also said that he was unsure if he had ever issued an order of “zero” contact for both parents, but he did so at that hearing.

Britney Haynes, 18, of Hillsboro was indicted by a Highland County grand jury Oct. 6 and charged with two second-degree felonies (felonious assault and endangering children) and one third-degree felony (a second charge of endangering children). She is currently out on bond, and a jury trial is currently scheduled for March.

The children’s father, Jacob Perkins, is not facing criminal charges. He is named as a parent on the complaint in Juvenile Court, although the children were in Haynes’ legal custody, according to court documents. On Oct. 19, Bolek said that the father was seeking to rescind affidavits of paternity he previously signed for both children. As of Friday’s hearing, genetic testing results were not available.

During Friday afternoon’s adjudication hearing, which was over two hours long, Highland County Assistant Prosecutor Molly Bolek presented three witnesses. Other counsel present for the hearing were Highland County Prosecutor Anneka Collins, on behalf of the state; Jason Despetorich, representing Haynes; Bill Armintrout, representing Perkins; and guardian ad litem Denny Kirk, appearing on behalf of the children.

Although Perkins attended the hearing and provided testimony, Haynes was not present.

“I do know her wishes and will proceed in her absence,” Despetorich told Greer.

“So you knew she would not be here today?” the judge asked.

“I knew there was a possibility she might not show up,” Despetorich said. “We had that discussion.”

Bolek’s first witness, Dr. Jonathan Thackeray of Dayton Children’s Hospital, was declared by the court as an expert witness. He said he is board-certified in child abuse pediatrics as well as general pediatrics and specializes in the “prevention, diagnosis and treatment of children with different forms of possible maltreatment.”

Thackeray testified that he evaluated Haynes’ second child, who was 3 months old at the time, on Sept. 10. He said he gave her a “head-to-toe” examination, along with reviewing her X-ray results and other records.

Bolek presented multiple exhibits with photos of the 3-month-old taken at Dayton Children’s Hospital. Thackeray explained the photos and testified about the various injuries documented, including:

• Bruising around her right eye,” her back on “different areas,” including around her “spinal column,” near both shoulder blades and on her “left shoulder area;” “multiple” bruises on her torso; bruises on her left “upper chest wall” and left arm;

• “Small papular lesions” consistent with insect bites on her right arm;

• “Significant hair loss” on the back of the 3-month-old’s head and glue in the child’s hair.

Following a review of the photos, Bolek then directed Thackeray to diagrams of an infant’s skeletal system on a board. After giving a general description of the child’s injuries, Thackeray outlined the results of the 3-month-old’s X-rays on the diagram as follows:

• A fracture of the left parietal skull.

• Multiple rib fractures in various stages of healing, including the fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth, 10th, 11th ribs on multiple sides (left, right, back, lateral). Thackeray also said there were “some multiple fractures in the same rib,” in some instances.

• An “angulated mid-shaft” fracture to the left humerus and a fracture to the left ulna, along with multiple right arm fractures.

• A fracture of “the long bone from the hip to the knee, closer to the knee;” and a “fracture of the bigger of the two bones going from the knee to the ankle.”

• “Bone irregularities” suggesting a right shoulder blade fracture.

Thackeray testified that “based on the healing,” the injuries “weren’t all sustained at the same time.” He said he ordered additional testing to gauge the child’s bone health because it’s “unusual to see any child, or any person, with that many fractures.”

The “battery of tests” for bone health “came back normal,” Thackeray testified. He said they also did testing of the child’s blood due to the bruising found across the child’s body.

Bolek asked about the “ramifications of delaying diagnosis and treatment of fractures.”

“It depends on the fracture,” Thackeray said. “It could be prolonged pain. It could be abnormal healing, which could lead to more long-term complications. Depending on the cause — if abuse is the cause of the injury and it’s not detected quickly, it’s in theory leaving the child exposed to additional risk for harm.”

“Based on your experience as a pediatrician and treating patients that have suffered abuse, what is your opinion regarding [the infant’s] injuries?” Bolek asked.

“[The baby]’s got a number of bruises and I think 24 or 25 fractures,” Thackeray said. “I evaluated the possibility of bone disorders and bleeding disorders, but honestly, there’s very few things that could cause both a lot of bruises and a lot of fractures in a child, medically. Those evaluations were normal.

“This is a child that’s suffered numerous episodes of trauma, and in a child her age, in the absence of significant number of accidental traumas, this is child physical abuse.”

Bolek then began questioning Thackeray regarding Haynes’ other child, who was 15 months old at the time the complaint was filed. Thackeray testified that he also performed a physical exam of the 15-month-old on Sept. 10.

Thackeray reviewed photos from the 15-month-old’s file, where he pointed out “multiple bruises” on the child’s left cheek; and a rash that he believed was the result of insect bites on the child’s arms and legs, chest, torso, diaper area and back. In addition, Thackeray testified that the child had multiple bruises around the spinal column and a “large mass” (which the original complaint had described as a hernia, but Thackeray said was later determined to be a “fluid-filled cyst”).

Thackeray also testified that the child appeared to have developmental delays, as the child didn’t speak “throughout the hospitalization” and that the child could stand by “holding onto the bars of the crib,” but not unsupported.

“What do you believe is the most likely explanation of [the 15-month-old’s] injuries?” Bolek asked.

“The bruising of the face is also concerning for physical abuse,” Thackeray said. “A 15-month-old, especially one who isn’t able to ambulate or walk around on its own, it would be difficult for [the child] to bruise [the child’s] face.”

During cross examination, Despetorich said that the medical records reviewed during the hearing included records written by nurses, doctors and licensed social workers at the hospital, not just Thackeray’s. Thackeray also testified that he did not take the photos. Collins objected, saying “the standard of a picture is not who took it, but whether it’s a true and accurate depiction of the subject on the day in question.”

“These were taken, not by me, but they were taken on September 10th,” Thackeray said.

Despetorich asked about the age of various bruises on the 3-month-old. Thackeray said there was “no scientific basis” to tell the date of a bruise. Despetorich also asked Thackeray if there was “any indication from physically looking at the child, without X-raying the child,” that the 3-month-old had suffered various fractures.

“No, sir,” Thackeray said.

After further discussion of the 3-month-child’s fractures and tests, along with the bruises and rashes seen on the 15-month-old under cross examination, Kirk then questioned Thackeray.

“You were asked questions about the age of the bruises,” Kirk said. “Is that really the main concern here, or is it the fact that we have bruises present?”

“What’s concerning about [the 3-month-old] is multiple bruises, but also multiple fractures,” Thackeray said. “A child [the 3-month-old]’s age really shouldn’t have any bruise, let alone multiple bruises on different areas of the body, so yes, the fact that they’re there is really concerning.”

Thackeray also testified that it’s standard procedure to “do a series of X-rays because we know that infants will have fractures and not show outward signs,” plus an infant “obviously can’t tell you” if and where they are experiencing pain.

Kirk asked if the injuries were ones “that could happen rather easily” or would require “quite a bit of force.”

“It’s tough to quantify how much force,” Thackeray said. “It’s more force than we see from the routine care of babies. We don’t see fractures and bruises from bathing or changing or playing or bouncing a baby on the knee or tossing a baby in the area and catching them. We don’t see bruises or fractures from that normal amount of child care, so it’s an excessive amount of force.”

“There’s probably no one act that could cause all that at the same time, correct?” Kirk asked.

“There is no one act that could cause all that at the same time,” Thackeray said. “And the healing of the bones indicate that there’s been fractures sustained at different times.”

Thackeray also testified that possible neglect is “something to consider” with the 15-month-old.

Under redirect examination, Bolek asked about “behavioral signs” a child could show if he or she suffers a bone fracture.

“In a child [the 3-month-old’[s age], you might expect irritability, crying, depending on when the fracture was sustained, loss of movement of the limb,” Thackeray said. “A broken left arm, [the child] might not move that arm for a period of time or it might be really painful when it’s moved.

“Often, you will see swelling at the time the fracture is sustained, so there often are physical findings, but they’re really limited to around the time the fracture is sustained.”

Thackeray added that rib injuries are more difficult to spot.

“Are those changes that a routine caregiver would notice with their child? Is that commonly reported?” Bolek asked.

“The swelling, the loss of use, the pain with movement of the extremity would be reasonably noticed by a caregiver, yes,” Thackeray said.

After approximately one hour of testimony, Thackeray was excused, and Perkins was called as the next witness.

Perkins testified that he moved out of Haynes’ home “in mid-June toward July” 2020 due to the couple separating. Since then, he said he had primarily spoken to the children on the phone and had communicated with Haynes via text and through social media. From Aug. 12 to Sept. 8, Perkins had no contact with Haynes or the children due to an order issued from Hillsboro Municipal Court, after Perkins was charged with domestic violence. The order was lifted Sept. 3, Perkins said.

“On September 8, what prompted you to have contact with the children?” Bolek asked.

“She said that my kids whined too much and that she did not want to have [the 3-month-old] anymore,” Perkins said.

Perkins testified that when he picked up the 3-month-old on the night of Sept. 8, Haynes said she wanted to give him “full custody” of the baby. Bolek admitted as evidence what Perkins said was a “written agreement” that Perkins wrote, with Haynes telling him “exactly what to write.”

“The note stated that ‘I will give Jacob Perkins custody of [the 3-month-old]. He is responsible for medical appointments and/or any injuries that happen to [the child],” Perkins said, and testified that Haynes signed the note.

Perkins said that he noticed bruising on the infant’s face and swelling on the child’s arm as well as “softness on the back of [the child’s] skull,” but when he asked Haynes about it, she said that “it was taken care of.”

Perkins testified that he took the infant to the hospital on Sept. 9, in the “mid-afternoon” and that Haynes said “not to involve her.” Through cross examination, Despetorich asked why Perkins waited so long to take the child to the hospital.

“At the moment, I didn’t know what to do, and I also had been told it was taken care of,” Perkins said.

Despetorich asked if Children Services had been “involved in this case before,” such as for an alleged injury to the 15-month-old. Perkins said “there was no investigation” and that he hadn’t spoken to Children Services about it.

Kirk questioned Perkins regarding the note that he said Haynes dictated to him regarding custody.

“I’m a little confused as to why she mentioned something about ‘any injuries,” Kirk said. “Do you know why she said that, or did she explain?”

“I’m not sure why,” Perkins said.

“Did it strike you as odd?” Kirk asked.

“Yes,” Perkins said.

“Now, looking back, does it make more sense?” Kirk asked.

“Yes,” Perkins said.

Regarding Perkins taking the 3-month-old on Sept. 8, he said he “was not allowed” to take the 15-month-old at the same time. He also testified that while he was still living in the home, Haynes was the “primary caregiver” of both children and that he did not witness her being “rough” with either child.

Kirk also asked if Perkins was “aware of any kind of bugs or fleas in the home.” Perkins said that they had a dog and a cat in the house and that they had fleas and that he had treated the house before the 3-month-old was born.

“You heard today the doctor testify today that these injuries appear to be from non-accidental causes,” Kirk said. “Are you saying you didn’t have anything to do with it?”

“I had nothing to do with it,” Perkins said.

“Do you know who did?” Kirk asked.

“No, I do not,” Perkins said.

Perkins was dismissed after 20 minutes, and Bolek introduced the third and final witness, Highland County Sheriff’s Office Detective Sergeant Vincent Antinore.

Antinore testified that he was called to the Highland District Hospital emergency room on the evening of Sept. 9, where Perkins had brought the 3-month-old. As Dr. Thackeray did, Antinore reviewed photos taken of the child at the hospital

Antinore said that he interviewed both of the infant’s parents and that Perkins told him he had taken the baby on Sept. 8 and that he had a “handwritten note that was between him and Britney that he believed granted him custody” of the baby.

“I later confirmed this with Britney during an interview,” Antinore said. “She stated me that she did in fact give Jacob custody on this handwritten note on Sept. 8.”

Antinore said that Perkins told him that a protection order had been dropped and that on Sept. 8, Haynes had contacted him asking him to get the 3-month-old.

“Were you able to verify, in regard to the criminal history and the time frames Jacob Perkins reported?” Bolek asked.

Antinore said that he had, and that a criminal complaint against Perkins for domestic violence had been filed July 26 and that the case, as well as the temporary protection order, had been dismissed as of Sept. 3. The detective also reviewed criminal complaints filed against Perkins and against Haynes on Aug. 14, each for an alleged domestic violence offense Aug. 12.

Antinore testified that after speaking with Perkins, he prepared a search warrant for Haynes’ home. Haynes and the 15-month-old were both present at the home at the time the search warrant was executed on Sept. 9, he said.

“What did you observe at the residence?” Bolek asked.

“It started at the front porch. It was just deplorable conditions,” Antinore said. “It was dirty. As soon as we entered the residence, there were just things stacked from floor to ceiling. I had to weave a path to the kitchen and the bedroom.”

Antinore added that there was a cat trapped inside a bathroom, and when they opened the door “they had to exit the residence because the smell was so bad we had to give it some time to air out before we could go back in.” He later testified that once they went into the bathroom, they found a litter box “hadn’t been cleaned and was piled full of cat feces.”

Antinore reviewed photos from the inside and outside of the home, where he described “junk piled up” to the point there was “no room to move;” a portable crib “full of stuff and filth and dirt;” and a kitchen with “piles of things” and “piles of dirty dishes and general dirty living conditions.”

Several photos of the kitchen were devoted to insect feces on the wall; roaches “crawling on the wall and in and out of the trash can” as well as crawling on the dishes in the sink and on the stove; and an exposed outlet that he said could potentially cause injury.

In Haynes’ bedroom, they found “stuff piled on top of her bed.” The 3-month-old’s crib, which Antinore said was “absolutely filthy and disgusting,” also had roaches crawling inside the crib.

Also found on the bedroom was Haynes’ phone, which was seized as evidence. Antinore testified that Haynes told him one conversation found by investigators was between her and her stepfather. He said that the conversation showed Haynes saying that she felt sick and wanted to go to the hospital.

In the conversation, the texts show the stepfather said that Haynes’ mother suggested taking the children to “JP,” whom Antinore said they assumed is Perkins, and Haynes replying “Do you really want him to see the bruises on their faces?” The stepfather also suggested calling a squad, and Haynes said she didn’t want to take the children in the squad because they “have marks on them.”

Antinore testified that he spoke to Haynes regarding the text conversation and that she acknowledged that they were her messages. He also interviewed Haynes regarding the injuries to the 3-month-old.

“When I first started asking her, she provided several different versions of how these injuries could have occurred,” Antinore said. “Initially, she blamed it on Jacob. At one point, she blamed it on her sister. Then she blamed it on a babysitter and claimed she didn’t know the babysitter’s name. I later confronted her about that and she did come up with a name of the babysitter.

“Eventually, after several versions, she made an admission that she had caused the injuries.”

Antinore said that he asked Haynes about the various specific injuries, including the 3-month-old’s fractured arms.

“She explained that one arm was stuck between the crib and the wall and that she pulled it out,” Antinore said. “She said she believed it caused an injury and she heard some type of noise.”

Antinore said that Haynes claimed the other arm injury was caused during a diaper change when Haynes “rolled [the baby] over on top” of the outstretched arm and “heard that arm pop.”

For the infant’s leg injuries, Haynes said that one leg injury was like the arm injury in which the leg was “stuck between the crib and the wall” and Haynes “forced it out.” Haynes told Antinore that she “kneeled on” the baby’s other leg during a diaper change and “put her body weight” on the baby’s leg while “searching for wipes.”

“Did she make any statements about [the 3-month-old’s] rib fractures?” Bolek asked.

“When I asked her about the various injuries, she said when she would pick [the 3-month-old] up, it sounded like a bag of crumbled potato chips,” Antinore said. “She believed Jacob could have caused those injuries.”

Antinore said Haynes also “gave various versions of how” the baby could have gotten a black eye” before saying the 3-month-old’s “head hit her collarbone.”

“Did she make any statements about [the baby’s] head injury?” Bolek asked.

“She did,” Antinore said. “She gave me various versions of how it could have occurred before finally settling on a believable one.”

Antinore said that Haynes said she was changing the infant and “laid her down harder than she should have” and hit the child’s head on a “hard toy.”

“I did ask her about seeking medical attention, knowing that she’d heard these pops and [the baby’s] cries,” Antinore said. “She stated that she didn’t get medical attention because she didn’t want to get in trouble and she didn’t want Children’s Services involved.”

Antinore said that Haynes told him “she felt like she never connected with [the 3-month-old], that she didn’t like [the 3-month-old] and that she didn’t want [the 3-month-old]. She said that she’d explored options in the past for putting [the 3-month-old] up for adoption and that if there was a way she could sign her rights away, she would certainly do so.”

Antinore said he “asked her if her feelings toward [the 3-month-old] may have affected the way she cared for [the 3-month-old], and she said she agreed with that.”

During cross examination, Despetorich asked if Antinore could say that the text conversation purportedly between Haynes and her stepfather was “true and accurate” and whether texts within the conversation could have been deleted or manipulated.

“To my knowledge, I’ve never investigated a case where messages were manipulated,” Antinore said. “Several cases where they were deleted or missing, but I don’t think manipulated or changed.”

“You don’t know that Britney actually sent the text messages the way they were presented in those, do you?” Despetorich asked.

“She stated that she did,” Antinore said. “I asked her if she sent those messages or if she recalled that conversation, and she said yes.”

Despetorich also asked about the various interviews conducted with Haynes. Antinore said that he spoke with her at her home as well as at the Highland County Sheriff’s Office. Detective Engel of the HCSO also interviewed Haynes, both on the way to the sheriff’s office and at the office itself, he said.

Antinore testified that Haynes changed her story “at least three” times during her initial approximately 15-minute interview with him, and that he was not aware of what Haynes told Engel but was “under the impression she did not give an admission.”

“During your interview, the second part of the one at the police station, [Haynes] then comes around saying some statements that she may have caused injuries to these children. Is that correct?” Despetorich asked.

“That’s correct,” Antinore said.

“They weren’t very definitive, were they?” Despetorich asked.

“I thought they were,” Antinore said. “She stated she caused the injuries and described how.”

“Did she say she ‘may have’ caused the injuries, or did she say ‘I did cause these injuries?’” Despetorich asked.

“I don’t remember her exact wording,” Antinore said.

Despetorich asked if it was “uncommon, toward the end of that last interview, just to tell the detective what he wants to know so she could leave.”

“Not in my experience,” Antinore said.

Antinore again said that Haynes changed her story “at least more than three” times and that he “believed the last version of events she gave” was “reliable.”

“Is that because that fits what you believe happened?” Despetorich asked.

“No,” Antinore said. “I don’t have a personal opinion on the case.”

After excusing Antinore, who testified for approximately 43 minutes, Bolek said that “the agency would rest” and asked to admit all exhibits presented during the hearing.

Despetorich objected to the two children’s certified medical records from Dayton Children’s Hospital because he said it “contains hearsay within hearsay.” He also objected to the photos of the conversation between Haynes and her stepfather because he said they “were hearsay and cannot be authenticated.”

Armintrout and Kirk said they had no objections to any of the exhibits.

Greer said that he would accept the text conversation and that “even without ruling” on the certified medical records, “the evidence is overwhelming to the court” that “the agency has proven all three counts, abuse, neglect and dependency,” for both children.

“I will again issue specific findings and make rulings on [the medical record exhibits],” Greer said. “All the agency’s exhibits accept [the medical record exhibits] will be admitted, and I’ll make a further decision [on those] for adjudication.

“There’s no question all the exhibits for disposition are admissible. Any evidence under the juvenile rules, including hearsay and documentary evidence, if relevant and material, or admissible.”

Following a brief recess, Bolek said counsel had reached a “partial agreement on disposition,” including for the “agency to be granted temporary custody for one year,” through Sept. 11, 2021. Bolek said the agency and the mother’s attorney disagreed on the “case plan,” as they asked the court to implement the recommendations of the guardian ad litem, “and no contact order.”

“The agency’s position, specifically in regard to the mother, is that the no contact order remain in place,” Bolek said. “In regard to the father, we ask that it remain in place and be reevaluated after genetic testing results come back to determine if he is, in fact, the father.”

Despetorich said that he was requesting the case plan be amended to “change the no contact order between the mother and the children” to permit them to communicate via video conferencing or “telecommunication.”

“I think that that could ensure that there is no safety issues between the mother and the children and the children are too young to be traumatized by any potential visitation with the mother at this point in time,” Despetorich said. “In part, we are making that request because she has not had visitation with her child since September of 2020. In addition to that, we want to avoid any type of abandonment argument for potential PCC [Permanent Court Commitment] of the child in the future.”

Despetorich said they also opposed a recommendation for Haynes to undergo a psychological evaluation.

Armintrout said that pending the genetic testing results, Perkins was hoping that “the agency will work with him on visitation starting at the advocacy center” and that Perkins is reviewing the case plan.

Kirk responded to Despetorich’s requests and argued that “it would be appropriate to continue the no contact order for both parents” until “paternity is established,” and he is recommending having a monitor present for in-person visitation between Perkins and the children in the event that order is lifted.

“As to the mother, she didn’t even show up today,” Kirk said. “That shows how much she’s really worried about this. To me, there should be a no-contact order. We’ve got a pending felony and the evidence speaks for itself.

“I don’t see where a no contact order could then be used against the mother in a permanent custody matter because she’s under a court order to have no contact. I think that’s different from when you choose to have no contact.”

Kirk added that keeping the no contact order for the mother was “fully appropriate.”

“She also made statements that she doesn’t want her child, at least according to Detective Antinore,” Kirk said. “I’m not sure she’s real interested in seeing the child.”

Regarding the case plan, Kirk said that he felt it “lacked a few things” and that his recommendation was to assign parenting classes and to order “a full psychological” evaluation of “both parties, especially the mother.”

Bolek agreed with Kirk’s recommendation regarding the no contact order.

“The court makes determinations based on what’s best for children, not their parents,” she said. “I don’t think at this point it has anything to do with what’s best for the children. It sounds like something the mother desires, and I would ask the court to continue the no-contact order.”

Greer said that the no-contact order would be continued for both parents.

“The mother — this court is convinced, in considering the evidence — did not want this child,” Greer said. “The child was only 3 months old, and she turned the child over to the dad.

“These injuries are horrific, and only a monster, in this court’s judgment and opinion, could inflict such an injury on a baby.”

For the ruling, see: https://highlandcountypress.com/Content/In-The-News/In-The-News/Article/Judge-Greer-issues-decision-on-alleged-child-abuse-case/2/20/62118 

Add new comment

This is not for publication.
This is not for publication.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.
Article comments are not posted immediately to the Web site. Each submission must be approved by the Web site editor, who may edit content for appropriateness. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission while the web site editor reviews and approves it. Note: All information on this form is required. Your telephone number and email address is for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.
CAPTCHA This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions. Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.