YouTube
|
Twitter/HCPSports
|
YouTube/HCPSports
|
Twitter
|
Facebook
|
Home
To Advertise Call (937) 840-9490
In The News
Headlines
Social
Education
Sports
Hillsboro
Greenfield
Lynchburg
Fairfield
Whiteoak
Southern State
Opinions
Dr. Andy Bowman
Jeanette Sekan
Rory Ryan
Steve Roush
Jim Thompson
Christine Tailer
Jim Surber
Letters to Editor
R.D. Hottle
Obituaries
Classifieds
Place an ad online
Extras
REM
Community Calendar
Sports Calendar
Real Estate & Auctions
Star Cinemas
Display Ads
Photo Galleries
Videos
Link Directory
Life
About Us
Delays & Closings
Friday, November 8, 2019
SHARE ONLINE
Please, make sure that you have entered valid email addresses!
Link
Share with
recipients` e-mail
From
your e-mail
Subject
optional
Comments
optional
Generate New Image
Get Audio Code
Type the code from the image
Please, reenter the code in the captcha!
The link was successfully Sent!
Ooops!:( An error has occurred!
Comments (1)
The stethoscope is not just a prop
Dr. Jane Orient
By Jane M. Orient, M.D.
Executive Director
Association of American Physicians and Surgeons
Stock photos of “healthcare workers” who attend patients – physicians are no longer distinguishable – usually feature a stethoscope draped around the neck.
But some, such as cardiologist Eric Topol, consider the stethoscope obsolete, nothing more than a pair of “rubber tubes.”
The most important part of the stethoscope is the part between the ears. But some think that will be replaced by artificial intelligence, and the rubber tubes by sophisticated electronic gizmos costing at least ten times as much as the humble stethoscope.
High tech is wonderful and increasingly capable, but if the stethoscope is dying, so is the art of clinical medicine.
The proper use of the stethoscope requires the doctor to touch, listen to the patient, and spend some time with a living person, not a computer. Patient and physician must cooperate: “Stop breathing,” “Take a big deep breath,” “Lean forward,” and so on.
It may be true, as Dr. James Thomas said, that graduates in internal medicine and emergency medicine miss as many as half of murmurs using a stethoscope. There are several reasons for this. One is not taking enough time to listen in a quiet room, and failing to perform the special maneuvers required to bring out an otherwise inaudible murmur (lean forward and exhale fully, turn onto your left side, squat then stand up, etc.).
The other is inadequate training. There are excellent recordings of heart sounds and murmurs, which of course would take time away from the time-devouring electronic medical record or “systems-based” medicine. And a recording is not the same thing as a live patient. Much of today’s teaching in physical diagnosis may be by “patient instructors”—paid actors pretending to be patients, who are evaluating the students as the students examine them. Rounds may be in a conference room, focused on the electronic record, instead of at the bedside.
In the old days, all the members of the team got to examine a real patient who had an interesting finding, with the patient’s permission and under the supervision of an attending physician. It seemed to me that patients usually enjoyed being the center of attention and the star of the show, and hearing the professor discuss their case. We learned how to help patients to sit up, and about hairy chests, layers of extra insulation, noisy lung sounds, shortness of breath, and other impediments to an easy examination.
The stethoscope is not just for heart murmurs. It’s for finding subtleties in careful, slow measurement of the blood pressure. It’s for extra or abnormal heart sounds. One can sometimes hear evidence of vascular problems inside the skull, or in the arteries supplying the brain, kidneys, or limbs. Or signs of intestinal obstruction. One can check to make sure a breathing tube is in the right place.
I don’t know of any bedside technologic wonders for examining the lungs. The stethoscope can detect sensitive signs of heart failure, pneumonia, fluid in the chest, collapsed lung, or airway obstruction. One can listen frequently to monitor changes in the patient’s status – much more efficiently than bringing the portable x-ray machine around.
The stethoscope works even when the power is off, the batteries are dead, the computer is down, or some circuit in the ultrasound device is malfunctioning. It works in facilities too poor to have the latest technology, or with patients who can’t afford to pay for a more expensive examination.
The stethoscope has tremendous capabilities in trained hands. Patients might want to evaluate whether they have a clinician who knows how to use it or is just carrying around a prop or status symbol. If you have symptoms suggestive of a heart or lung problem, does the doctor listen to all the lung fields – upper, mid, and lower, front and back? To at least four places for heart sounds? Are you asked to cough, say “e,” whisper something, take deep breaths or slow quiet ones, or do other maneuvers if something in the history or examination suggests a possible problem? Is the tv off, and are visitors asked to be quiet?
Everybody including doctors loves fancy technology. But before we toss out the old reliable tools, backed by two centuries of experience, how about some serious comparative studies like those the proponents of evidence-based medicine constantly demand?
Jane M. Orient, M.D. obtained her undergraduate degrees in chemistry and mathematics from the University of Arizona in Tucson, and her M.D. from Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons in 1974. She has been in solo private practice since 1981 and has served as executive director of the Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS) since 1989.
1
1
Comments
Newest ▼
Oldest ▲
A lot of good points in this column. The time and talents of physicians is key to make medical costs to a minimum.
This comment has been hidden due to low approval.
Matthew
11/9/2019 11:04:00 AM
1
Submit A Comment
Please fill out the form below to submit a comment.
*
indicates a required field
Comment
*
Your Name
Email
Phone
Article comments are not posted immediately to the Web site. Each submission must be approved by the Web site editor, who may edit content for appropriateness. There may be a delay of 24-48 hours for any submission while the web site editor reviews and approves it.
Note:
All information on this form is required. Your telephone number is for our use only, and will not be attached to your comment.
Submit
X
Search only accepts letters and numbers.
Most Viewed
Most Commented
Hillsboro man gets community control in meth trafficking case
(1820 views)
McClain's Kendyll Toney signs letter of intent to play collegiate basketball
(1463 views)
Clinton-Massie grad Chayse Wolf named to 2022 Toyota Team USA Wheelchair Basketball roster
(1035 views)
Benefit to be held for Link and Dugger families in Leesburg
(799 views)
Hillsboro City Council rejects emergency fireworks ban ahead of new law taking effect; ordinance will have 2nd reading
(796 views)
Yellen says recession is not inevitable; CEOs say it is on the way
(4 comments)
Commissioners approve bid for Concord Township school demo project; receive Palomino Solar updates in correspondence
(4 comments)
Sandy has replaced Earl as bartender
(4 comments)
Supreme Court strikes down New York's restrictions on concealed carry
(3 comments)
Poll: Majority of Republicans, Independents fear abuse of 'red flag' laws
(3 comments)
Our app is now available!
YouTube
|
Twitter/HCPSports
|
Twitter
|
Facebook
|
Life
|
Home
Content © 2018 Cameco Communications • 128 S. High Street • Hillsboro, Ohio 45133
The Highland County Press
Telephone 937-840-9490 • Fax 937-840-9492 • Email
hcpress@cinci.rr.com
Privacy Policy
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##